{"audit":"machine-observer-x402-practice-audit","version":1,"checkedAt":"2026-09-04T13:24:34.106Z","score":87,"grade":"B","policy":{"protocol":"x402 v2","network":"Base mainnet","paidRoutesAudited":11,"probeMethod":"Unpaid GET against each published paid route. No payment header is sent and no settlement occurs.","neverDisclosed":["PAY_TO","facilitator credentials","payment signatures","buyer identity"],"noChargePolicy":"A route that declines to charge because the intelligence core is unavailable is scored as correct behaviour, not as a missing challenge.","editorialFirewall":"This audit measures seller conformance only. It cannot alter editorial treatment, source confidence or index scores."},"services":[{"id":"answer","endpoint":"/api/x402/answer","priceUsd":0.001,"role":"starter","latencyMs":410,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":23,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"1000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"410 ms"}]},{"id":"decision","endpoint":"/api/x402/decision","priceUsd":0.003,"role":"flagship","latencyMs":1249,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":23,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"3000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"1249 ms"}]},{"id":"best-practice","endpoint":"/api/x402/best-practice","priceUsd":0.002,"role":"paid","latencyMs":535,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":23,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"2000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"535 ms"}]},{"id":"history","endpoint":"/api/x402/history","priceUsd":0.001,"role":"paid","latencyMs":883,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":22,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"1000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"883 ms"}]},{"id":"transfer","endpoint":"/api/x402/transfer","priceUsd":0.003,"role":"paid","latencyMs":1147,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":23,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"3000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"1147 ms"}]},{"id":"meta-analysis","endpoint":"/api/x402/meta-analysis","priceUsd":0.005,"role":"paid","latencyMs":1276,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":23,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"5000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"1276 ms"}]},{"id":"ad-best-bid","endpoint":"/api/x402/ad-intelligence/best-bid","priceUsd":0.002,"role":"paid","latencyMs":1038,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":16,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"2000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"1038 ms"}]},{"id":"ad-competitive-density","endpoint":"/api/x402/ad-intelligence/competitive-density","priceUsd":0.002,"role":"paid","latencyMs":1181,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":16,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"2000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"1181 ms"}]},{"id":"ad-publisher-yield","endpoint":"/api/x402/ad-intelligence/publisher-yield","priceUsd":0.003,"role":"paid","latencyMs":1249,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":16,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"3000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"1249 ms"}]},{"id":"ad-attention-arbitrage","endpoint":"/api/x402/ad-intelligence/attention-arbitrage","priceUsd":0.005,"role":"paid","latencyMs":566,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":16,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"5000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"566 ms"}]},{"id":"ad-campaign-forecast","endpoint":"/api/x402/ad-intelligence/campaign-forecast","priceUsd":0.005,"role":"paid","latencyMs":1124,"status":402,"outcome":"payment_challenge","score":16,"maxScore":23,"checks":[{"label":"HTTP 402 payment challenge","ok":true,"points":4,"maxPoints":4,"detail":"HTTP 402"},{"label":"x402 v2","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":2},{"label":"Exact USDC payment on Base","ok":true,"points":3,"maxPoints":3,"detail":"exact · eip155:8453"},{"label":"Advertised amount matches the published price","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":"5000"},{"label":"Resource description and JSON mime type","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Seller identity metadata","ok":true,"points":2,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"Live value proof in the challenge","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":3,"detail":null},{"label":"Same-request retry instructions","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":2,"detail":null},{"label":"No account or API key required","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","ok":false,"points":0,"maxPoints":1,"detail":null},{"label":"Fast payment challenge","ok":true,"points":1,"maxPoints":1,"detail":"1124 ms"}]}],"discovery":[{"path":"/api/x402/catalog","ok":true,"status":200,"latencyMs":63},{"path":"/api/v1/buy","ok":true,"status":200,"latencyMs":764},{"path":"/openapi.json","ok":true,"status":200,"latencyMs":55},{"path":"/llms.txt","ok":true,"status":200,"latencyMs":50},{"path":"/.well-known/x402","ok":true,"status":200,"latencyMs":54},{"path":"/api/x402/health","ok":true,"status":200,"latencyMs":327}],"findings":[{"severity":"medium","service":"history","issue":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","detail":null},{"severity":"high","service":"ad-best-bid","issue":"Live value proof in the challenge","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-best-bid","issue":"Same-request retry instructions","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-best-bid","issue":"No account or API key required","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-best-bid","issue":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","detail":null},{"severity":"high","service":"ad-competitive-density","issue":"Live value proof in the challenge","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-competitive-density","issue":"Same-request retry instructions","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-competitive-density","issue":"No account or API key required","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-competitive-density","issue":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","detail":null},{"severity":"high","service":"ad-publisher-yield","issue":"Live value proof in the challenge","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-publisher-yield","issue":"Same-request retry instructions","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-publisher-yield","issue":"No account or API key required","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-publisher-yield","issue":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","detail":null},{"severity":"high","service":"ad-attention-arbitrage","issue":"Live value proof in the challenge","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-attention-arbitrage","issue":"Same-request retry instructions","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-attention-arbitrage","issue":"No account or API key required","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-attention-arbitrage","issue":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","detail":null},{"severity":"high","service":"ad-campaign-forecast","issue":"Live value proof in the challenge","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-campaign-forecast","issue":"Same-request retry instructions","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-campaign-forecast","issue":"No account or API key required","detail":null},{"severity":"medium","service":"ad-campaign-forecast","issue":"Idempotent paid retry advertised","detail":null}]}